Skip to content Accessibility info

Church Mutual Insurance Company Agent

PAYMENTS

Mail Payments to:
PO Box 2912
Milwaukee, WI 53201-2912

About Church Mutual Insurance Company

Protecting the Greater Good for Over 125 Years

For more than 125 years, Church Mutual has partnered with those who serve others—providing the coverage, support, and peace of mind needed to focus on what matters most. Since our founding in 1897, purpose-driven organizations have trusted us to safeguard their people, property, and mission.

Here’s how we help your mission thrive:

  • Tailored protection: Property and liability coverage designed specifically for your organization’s unique needs.
  • Empowering safety: Risk management tools and insights that promote safe, effective operations.
  • Responsive claims service: Support that understands the distinct challenges of mission-based organizations.
  • Shared purpose: A deep commitment to the values and work that drive your organization forward.