Skip to content Accessibility info

Ministry Q&A: Why Should We Request a Certificate of Insurance When Another Organization Wants to Use Our Church?

Ministry Q&A: Why Should We Request a Certificate of Insurance When Another Organization Wants to Use Our Church?

Sora Shimazaki

Ministry Q&A: Why Should We Request a Certificate of Insurance When Another Organization Wants to Use Our Church?

Ministry Question:

Why should we request a certificate of insurance when another organization wants to use our church facility?

Ministry Answer:

This is one of the most common questions we receive from churches and ministry leaders.

When an outside organization, community group, school, nonprofit, business, or other third party wants to use your church's facilities, obtaining a current Certificate of Insurance (COI) is an important risk management practice. A certificate of insurance helps verify that the organization has insurance coverage in place and provides valuable information regarding the types and limits of coverage they carry.

At a minimum, churches should consider reviewing:

  • General Liability coverage limits
  • Medical Payments coverage
  • Damage to Rented Premises coverage
  • Policy effective dates
  • Insurance carrier information
  • Whether the church has been added as an Additional Insured, when appropriate and approved by the carrier
  • Sexual Misconduct Liability and/or Abuse & Molestation Liability coverage limits when children, youth, or vulnerable adults are involved
  • Evidence of safeguarding, screening, and child protection practices when applicable

However, it is important to understand that a certificate of insurance alone is not enough.

A certificate of insurance is only one component of a comprehensive facility use risk management strategy. Churches should also consider utilizing a well-written Facility Use Agreement that clearly outlines responsibilities, expectations, and risk allocation between the parties.

Whenever appropriate and permitted by legal counsel, the Facility Use Agreement should also contain indemnification and hold harmless provisions designed to protect the church or ministry from liabilities arising out of the third party's activities.

Special Consideration: Activities Involving Children and Vulnerable Adults

If the organization requesting use of your facilities serves children, youth, students, seniors, or other vulnerable populations, churches should consider conducting additional due diligence beyond reviewing general liability coverage.

Ministry leaders may wish to request information regarding:

  • Sexual Misconduct and Molestation Liability coverage
  • Abuse and Molestation Liability coverage limits
  • Background screening practices (This may include local, state, nationwide and international background checks)
  • Volunteer and employee screening procedures
  • Child protection policies
  • Training requirements
  • Supervision standards
  • Incident reporting procedures

While insurance is only one component of an effective safeguarding program, the absence of Sexual Misconduct Liability or Abuse and Molestation Liability coverage can create significant concerns when organizations are working with vulnerable populations.

Churches should carefully evaluate whether the user organization's insurance program includes appropriate Sexual Misconduct Liability or Abuse and Molestation Liability coverage and whether the coverage limits appear reasonable for the nature and scope of the activities being conducted.

Just as importantly, ministry leaders should not assume that all organizations working with children or vulnerable adults maintain these coverages. Verification should be part of the facility use review process whenever these exposures are present.

Failure to evaluate these risks may expose the church or ministry to significant financial, legal, reputational, and ministry-related consequences if an allegation, claim, investigation, or lawsuit arises from activities conducted on church property.

As part of sound stewardship and risk management, churches should consult with their legal counsel, insurance professionals, and risk management advisors regarding appropriate facility use requirements and insurance expectations for organizations serving children and vulnerable adults.

Why This Matters

Far too often, churches allow outside groups to use their facilities based on goodwill, longstanding relationships, or verbal agreements without obtaining current insurance documentation or signed facility use agreements.

While these arrangements may seem harmless, they can create significant liability exposures.

Consider the following examples:

  • A visitor is injured during a third-party event.
  • Property is damaged during facility use.
  • A fire originates from a renter's activities.
  • A participant alleges negligence.
  • Equipment, furnishings, or church property are damaged.
  • A third party causes injuries that result in litigation.

Without adequate documentation, the church may find itself defending claims that arguably should have been transferred to the organization using the facility.

The Potential Consequences of Not Obtaining a Certificate of Insurance

Many ministry leaders do not realize that failing to obtain a current certificate of insurance may limit the church's ability to verify whether the user organization actually maintained insurance coverage at the time of the event.

Without a current COI, your church may be unable to confirm:

  • Whether insurance existed
  • Whether coverage was active on the event date
  • Whether sufficient liability limits were carried
  • Whether exclusions may apply
  • Whether your church was granted Additional Insured status when required

If an uninsured or underinsured organization causes damage or injury, the financial consequences may ultimately affect the church, its insurance program, and its resources.

The Importance of a Facility Use Agreement

A Facility Use Agreement is equally important.

A properly drafted agreement helps establish expectations and responsibilities before an event occurs. It can address:

  • Permitted activities
  • Areas authorized for use
  • Insurance requirements
  • Responsibility for property damage
  • Safety expectations
  • Cleanup obligations
  • Compliance requirements
  • Indemnification responsibilities
  • Hold harmless provisions
  • Event-specific risk considerations

Without a written agreement, disputes can arise regarding responsibility after an incident occurs.

Simply put, it is far easier to establish responsibilities before an event than to argue over them afterward.

Legal Review Is Essential

While facility use agreements are an important risk management tool, churches and ministries should not rely on generic templates downloaded from the internet or documents borrowed from another organization without first obtaining appropriate legal review.

Because laws governing contracts, indemnification provisions, hold harmless agreements, releases, facility usage, and nonprofit organizations vary by state and jurisdiction, we strongly recommend that churches and ministries have qualified legal counsel review any proposed facility use agreement prior to execution.

Legal counsel can help determine whether the agreement complies with applicable federal, state, and local laws and whether the contract appropriately addresses the unique needs, operations, and risk exposures of the ministry.

Periodic review is also important. An agreement that was legally sufficient several years ago may not adequately address current laws, regulations, court decisions, ministry activities, or emerging risks.

As part of sound governance and stewardship, ministry leaders should work with legal counsel to periodically evaluate and update facility use agreements to help ensure they remain relevant, enforceable, and aligned with current operational practices.

Why Churches Should Be Concerned About Assuming Another Organization's Liability

Churches and ministries should ask themselves an important question:

Why should our ministry assume liability for another organization's activities when reasonable risk management practices could help allocate responsibility appropriately?

When claims arise from facility use activities, the church's insurance carrier may become involved in investigating, defending, or paying covered claims.

Even when coverage applies, claims can have broader implications, including:

  • Increased loss history
  • Renewal underwriting scrutiny
  • Potential premium increases
  • Changes to coverage terms
  • Increased deductibles or self-insured retentions
  • Reduced market competitiveness during future renewals

Every claim matters.

Claims activity becomes part of the church's insurance history and may be reviewed by carriers during both new business and renewal underwriting processes.

For this reason, ministry leaders should carefully evaluate why they would voluntarily assume exposure that may rightfully belong to another organization.

Engaging in the Insurance Process Is Part of Good Stewardship

Risk management is not simply the responsibility of your insurance carrier, administrator, agent, or broker.

It is a shared responsibility.

Churches and ministries should actively engage in the insurance and risk management process by evaluating exposures, implementing safeguards, documenting agreements, and communicating with qualified advisors.

As the insured, your organization is ultimately responsible for:

  • Reviewing facility use practices
  • Maintaining current facility use agreements
  • Obtaining and reviewing certificates of insurance
  • Confirming insurance requirements are met
  • Consulting legal counsel regarding contractual protections
  • Obtaining legal review of facility use agreements before execution
  • Periodically reviewing facility use agreements to help ensure compliance with applicable federal, state, and local laws
  • Confirming organizational practices remain aligned with contractual requirements
  • Reporting material operational changes
  • Maintaining accurate organizational records
  • Reviewing policy information upon receipt
  • Evaluating whether current insurance limits remain appropriate
  • Implementing reasonable risk management and loss prevention measures

Good stewardship requires more than purchasing insurance. It requires thoughtful decision-making, proactive planning, and accountability.

Stewardship Extends Beyond Insurance

Churches and ministries are entrusted with valuable resources, facilities, people, and programs that support their mission.

Protecting those resources involves more than transferring risk through insurance.

It requires:

  • Organizational oversight
  • Active governance
  • Safety practices
  • Contract management
  • Due diligence
  • Facility controls
  • Risk assessments
  • Ongoing education

By implementing sound facility use procedures and holding outside users accountable for their responsibilities, ministry leaders can better protect the people, property, finances, and mission entrusted to their care.

Why Experience Matters When Choosing an Insurance Agency

Facility use exposures, contractual risk transfer, certificates of insurance, indemnification provisions, and Additional Insured requirements can be complex.

That is why working with professionals who understand ministry operations and ministry risk can make a meaningful difference.

At Republic Insurance Group, our Ministry Risk Management Team specializes in serving churches, denominations, ministry organizations, camps, schools, and faith-based nonprofits throughout the country.

We help ministry leaders:

  • Better understand facility use exposures
  • Evaluate contractual risk transfer strategies
  • Review insurance requirements
  • Strengthen stewardship practices
  • Improve organizational resilience
  • Support informed insurance decisions
  • Encourage proactive engagement in the risk management process

Our goal is to serve as a trusted resource by providing education, guidance, and ministry-specific expertise that helps organizations make informed decisions before problems arise.

Why Ministries Choose Republic Insurance Group

Churches and ministries need more than insurance policies.

They need experienced partners who understand ministry operations, governance responsibilities, stewardship obligations, and the unique challenges facing faith-based organizations.

With decades of ministry-focused experience, the Republic Insurance Group Ministry Risk Management Team is committed to helping ministries evaluate exposures, strengthen risk management practices, and make informed insurance decisions.

We believe informed ministries make better decisions, and better decisions help protect the mission, people, property, and resources entrusted to ministry leadership.

Strengthening Stewardship. Safeguarding Ministry

Before allowing any third party to use your facilities, we encourage ministry leaders to review their facility use procedures, insurance requirements, and contractual documentation.

Obtaining a current certificate of insurance and implementing a properly drafted Facility Use Agreement can be an important component of a comprehensive risk management strategy.

If you have questions regarding certificates of insurance, Additional Insured requirements, facility use agreements, contractual risk transfer, or your ministry's insurance program, we encourage you to contact a member of our team. We would be honored to assist you.

Important Disclaimer

This article is provided solely for general educational and informational purposes and should not be construed as legal, insurance, tax, financial, accounting, risk management, underwriting, contractual, or other professional advice.

References to certificates of insurance, facility use agreements, hold harmless provisions, indemnification agreements, contractual risk transfer, Additional Insured status, insurance requirements, or risk management practices are provided solely for educational purposes and may not be appropriate for every organization or circumstance.

A certificate of insurance does not amend, alter, extend, modify, or guarantee coverage. Coverage is determined solely by the terms, conditions, limitations, exclusions, endorsements, and provisions contained within the applicable insurance policy. Organizations should not rely solely upon a certificate of insurance when evaluating another party's insurance program.

The existence of a facility use agreement, hold harmless provision, indemnification agreement, Additional Insured endorsement, certificate of insurance, insurance requirement, or risk management procedure does not guarantee protection from claims, litigation, liability, regulatory action, property damage, injury, financial loss, or other adverse events.

Every church, ministry, and nonprofit organization remains solely responsible for evaluating its own risks, determining appropriate risk management practices, maintaining adequate insurance, obtaining appropriate contractual protections, safeguarding its property and people, and consulting qualified legal counsel and other professional advisors regarding its specific circumstances.

Organizations should consult qualified legal counsel regarding the drafting, interpretation, enforceability, and applicability of any facility use agreement, hold harmless agreement, indemnification provision, or contractual requirement.

Insurance coverage and contractual rights vary based upon jurisdiction, policy language, applicable law, specific facts, underwriting requirements, and individual circumstances.

Republic Insurance Group, LLC
Ministry Risk Management Team

"Helping Ministries Protect What Matters Most"